First in Property Management – Putting The Members Of Our Community FIRST!

Published on 22 September 2017 in Business
Matthew Selby (author)

Matthew Selby


First in Property Management is owned and operated by Michelle Pentifallo, a licensed Real Estate Broker. She’s local! She lives, works and enjoys spending time with her family and friends in our community. Her business is her reputation in the New Tampa/ Wesley chapel area, and the reputation of First in Property Management is one of professionalism and class. You won’t get a corporate feel to your experience because putting the members of this community first is what Michelle’s company is known for.

Communication is key with a property management firm and communication you will receive!

Michelle credits her success to her belief in God and the talents and gifts He's given her. She is an excellent communicator, providing customer service with care, concern, compassion and empathy while protecting the needs of her owners and tenants. Of special note is the referral business Michelle receives from owners with multiple properties. They refer their family and friends to local realtors referring their property management business; including Keller Williams, Coldwell Banker, Prudential Tropical, Exit Realty and Remax.

Nancy Cross says, “As a fellow Realtor, I rely on Michelle Pentifallo and First In Property Management to help my clients whenever they need property management services. My business model focuses solely on sales, so having someone I can rely upon to provide excellent service to my clients is critical. Thank you, Michelle! It is my absolute pleasure to do business with you!”

This year marks the 10th anniversary of First In Property Management! The company started at 28 units in a small office in Hunters Green and grew to 100 units in the first year! After her partner retired Michelle earned her Broker's license in 2009 and, as the sole broker, is currently managing over 200 properties in a beautiful facility with a full staff. First in Property Management is now a DBA of First In Real Estate Services, Inc.

“We came into this business at a time where so many of our neighbors became “accidental landlords.” Our relationship with this community has been one of helpfulness. There was a need for our service considering many of our clients had never rented their home before and needed direction. We were able to help them find the right tenants for the right price and they were able to keep their homes instead of losing them when the economy collapsed. We helped them and they helped our business grow in return. I know God put me on this path for a reason and I feel so good about what we’ve been able to do for this community and as a company over the past 10 years,” says Michelle. 

Michelle Pentifallo


Property Listings

First In Property Management displays our available properties on leading property listings to help you find or sell your property. We can even provide yard signage if your looking to sell your property. 

Tenant Screenings

First In Property Management performs background checks for tenant applicants including searching any criminal records, credit history, and past evictions.

Renting or Leasing

First In Property Management handles lease agreements with both the owners and applicants, advises of rental procedures, and delivers property keys to the approved applicant.

After Move-In Property Management & Finances

First In Property Management handles after move-in property management and finances so you don't have to. We collect rent for you and advise of late rent notices. We also handle lease renewals and re-markets.

 Maintenance, Repairs, or Emergencies

First In Property Management coordinates emergency repairs and maintenance with licensed and insured vendors. Tenants will have online access to submit any needed work orders.

Reviews and Testimonials:

“Michelle's professionalism and confidence helped me in the decision to rent my property. Nervous as I was, she and her team handled anything that came up. And when it was time to sell that property, Michelle and her team exceeded expectations again. We are forever grateful.” – Kelly Mccarthy

“Michelle has been awesome to work with. Being my first time as a "landlord" she has helped me overcome hurdles, has provided me access to her vendors, which provide prices not otherwise available to me, and most importantly she found a tenant before my home was even ready to list! She and her staff have been great and I highly recommend them!” – Farhaad Golkar

I personally have a condo here in Tampa and after years of renting out my properties on my own, I’ve decided that when it’s time to buy a new home and rent this condo out, Michelle will be my first call. I’ve known Michelle through my BNI group in New Tampa for some time now and I can honestly say I have nothing but confidence in her and her services. From everything I’ve heard and seen for myself, First in Property Management will take the headache out of being a landlord!   

Michelle is also a member of the local Wesley Chapel Chamber and on the Leadership team for BNI Business Leaders in New Tampa along with the youth leader at Brach of Christ church for Ignite. 

You can contact Michelle at (813) 345-8559 

Located in: The Grove at Wesley Chapel 

Address: 6013 Wesley Chapel Blvd, Suite 102C, Wesley Chapel, FL 33544



Article Gallery

Join the YMCA!
Request a quote for advertising

Most Read Articles